👑 Charles IV the Fair: The Last of the Direct Capetians (1322–1328)

The accession of Charles IV, called the Fair, in 1322, opens the final phase of the direct Capetian dynasty. The third son of Philip IV the Fair, he ascends to the throne after the brief reigns of his two older brothers, Louis X the Headstrong and Philip V the Tall, both of whom died without a surviving male heir. His accession confirms once again the principle that the crown of France passes through men, but it also underscores the growing fragility of dynastic succession.

Coronation of Charles IV the Fair: Unknown 14th-c. French artist, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Charles inherits a powerfully organized kingdom, whose institutions have been strengthened by previous reigns. The royal administration, the Parlement, taxation, and central government continue to grow stronger, while the monarchy still faces several tensions: relations with England, the Flemish question, relations with the papacy at Avignon, and internal discontent inherited from recent decades.

Surnamed “the Fair” like his father, Charles IV often appears in historiography as a sovereign less striking than Philip the Fair, less reformist than Philip V, and less conflict-prone than his immediate predecessors. Yet his reign is nonetheless important, as it closes the male line directly descended from Hugh Capet. Under his rule, the monarchy continues to function efficiently, but the absence of a male heir prepares a major rupture in the kingdom’s dynastic history.

The reign of Charles IV is characterized by a certain institutional continuity, but also by a progressive rise in succession-related stakes. Upon his death in 1328, no surviving son can succeed him. This disappearance ends more than three centuries of direct succession of the Capetians and opens the way to the accession of the Valois, in a context where competing claims to the French throne become of decisive importance.

The reign of Charles the Fair thus appears as a turning point: less spectacular than others, it nonetheless constitutes the conclusion of a long Capetian cycle and the prelude to a major political recomposition, soon dominated by the question of succession to the French throne.

---

I. 1322–1324: Charles IV’s Accession, Royal Remarriage, and Opening of the War of Saint-Sardos

Charles IV the Fair is crowned at Reims on February 21, 1322. He thereby becomes king of France and Navarre, continuing the brief reigns of his two older brothers, Louis X the Headstrong and Philip V the Tall. His accession confirms once again the exclusion of women from succession to the French throne, while highlighting the growing fragility of the direct Capetian line.

The beginning of the reign is marked by several decisions of a dynastic and political nature. On May 19, 1322, Pope John XXII annuls Charles IV’s marriage to Blanche of Burgundy, compromised since the Tower of Nesle affair. The king can thus contract a new union, celebrated at Provins on September 21, 1322, with Marie of Luxembourg, daughter of Emperor Henry VII. This remarriage strengthens the ties between the French crown and the house of Luxembourg.

Marriage of Charles IV the Fair and Marie of Luxembourg. Illumination from a manuscript of the Great Chronicles of France: French artist of the 14th century, Bibliothèque nationale de France, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The same year, Charles IV resumes a policy of expulsion against the Jews. On June 24, 1322, he orders a new expulsion, continuing the one decided in 1306 under Philip the Fair. This measure reflects a climate of religious suspicion, a search for resources, and royal control, already reinforced by accusations against the Jews in preceding years.

The Saint-Sardos Incident and the Opening of a New Conflict with England

In 1323, the reign of Charles IV steers toward a new crisis with England, arising from the feudal ambiguities surrounding the possession of Gascony. For several decades, the king of England has exercised his authority there as Duke of Aquitaine, but he remains, for these lands, the vassal of the king of France. This situation maintains recurring tensions: the Capetian monarchy seeks to have its suzerainty rights recognized more concretely, while the Plantagenets defend their political and judicial autonomy.

The affair erupts around the small bastide of Saint-Sardos, located in the Agenais. The place depends partly on a priory belonging to the abbey of Sarlat, outside the Duchy of Aquitaine. A dispute is brought before the Parlement of Paris, which rules in favor of the abbot and authorizes the founding of a bastide placed under royal protection. In December 1322, this decision is secured, and on October 15, 1323, a royal sergeant arrives on site to materialize the act of possession in the name of Charles IV.

In the night that follows, Raymond-Bernard of Montpezat, a Gascon lord hostile to this Capetian advance, attacks the site, sets the bastide on fire, and hangs the royal sergeant from the very post bearing the arms of the king of France. The event immediately transcends its local context: it is interpreted at court as a direct affront to royal authority. The seneschal of Gascony, Ralph Basset, is moreover suspected of having, if not ordered the operation, at least encouraged or covered for its perpetrators.

King Edward II of England, faced with serious political difficulties in his own realm, initially attempts to avoid escalation through apologies and promises of reparation. But the French court demands that those responsible appear before the king. Faced with English delays and Ralph Basset’s refusal to fully respond to summons, Charles IV has the confiscation of the Duchy of Gascony pronounced on July 1, 1324. This decision transforms the incident into open war.

From August 1324 onward, French royal troops, commanded notably by Charles of Valois, enter the campaign and quickly occupy much of the territory without encountering major resistance. The War of Saint-Sardos, relatively brief from a military standpoint, nonetheless reveals the extent of feudal rivalries between the two crowns. It further weakens the position of Edward II in England and leaves, after the agreements ending it, deep frustrations regarding territory and politics. In the longer term, it appears as one of the immediate precedents of the great Franco-English conflicts of the 14th century.

Toulouse, Cultural Center of the Capetian South

Alongside these political and military tensions, the years 1323–1324 witness an important event in the cultural history of the South. On November 8, 1323, in Toulouse, the Company of Gay Knowledge is founded, intended to maintain the poetic tradition in the Occitan language and to extend the heritage of the troubadours. This institution is held to be the ancestor of the future Academy of the Floral Games.

The first poetry competition organized by this institution takes place from May 1 to 3, 1324. It marks the beginning of a lasting literary tradition, associated with the promotion of courtly lyricism and the defense of the Occitan language in a kingdom now strongly integrated into the Capetian sphere. By its later prestige, this foundation is often considered one of the oldest literary circles in Western Europe.

---

II. 1325–1327: English Crisis, Diplomatic Balances, and the Final Years of the Reign

The final years of Charles IV the Fair’s reign are marked by the continuation of tensions with England, by diplomatic adjustments in Western Europe, and by the permanence of institutional and cultural activity in the kingdom. In the continuation of the War of Saint-Sardos, the Capetian monarchy remains engaged in indirect confrontation with Edward II, whose authority rapidly weakens across the Channel.

Intellectual Developments, Princely Tensions, and Economic Difficulties

The year 1325 is not distinguished by a single major event comparable to the Saint-Sardos crisis, but it reveals several important aspects of Charles IV the Fair’s reign: the evolution of intellectual debates in the kingdom, the persistence of princely rivalries in the Rhone valley region, and the fragility of economic balances at the end of the 1320s.

On the intellectual plane, the University of Paris lifts in 1325 the ban that had weighed on Thomism. This evolution testifies to a relative easing of doctrinal controversies arising in the previous century around the reception of Aristotle and the work of Thomas Aquinas. Long suspected in certain university circles, several theses associated with Thomism then regain a more legitimate place in Parisian teaching. This change is part of a broader movement of reorganization of scholastic thought, in which the University of Paris continues to play a central role at the level of Latin Christendom.

The same year is also marked by a severe drought in France. Chronicles report a poor cereal harvest, a sign of the persistent vulnerability of the agrarian economy after the crises of the early 14th century, but they also mention exceptionally good grape harvests. This contrast reminds us that climatic fluctuations do not uniformly affect agricultural production and that they can accentuate social tensions by striking basic necessities harder than commercial or prestigious crops. This situation is part of a broader European context still marked by the aftereffects of the great famine that began in 1315.

At the same time, princely rivalries continue in the eastern margins of the kingdom. The conflict opposing the Dauphin of Viennois, Guigues VIII, to the house of Savoy leads to the Battle of Varey, won on August 7, 1325 by the Dauphin’s troops against those of Count Edward of Savoy. The confrontation occurs in the context of ancient struggles between Dauphiné and Savoy for control of strategic positions in the Alpine and Rhone valley region. Guigues VIII’s victory does not end the conflict durably, but it momentarily strengthens the prestige of the Dauphin and illustrates the persistence of territorial competitions between neighboring principalities, at the border of the Kingdom of France and the Empire.

---

Franco-Scottish Alliance and the Fall of Edward II of England

In 1326, the international situation of Charles IV the Fair is dominated by the English crisis. In the continuation of the War of Saint-Sardos and persistent tensions over Gascony, the French monarchy seeks to maintain pressure on England, notably through the operation of alliances. It is in this context that the Treaty of Corbeil is concluded in April 1326 between France and Scotland, which renews the traditional alliance of the two kingdoms against the English crown, in continuation of the old Auld Alliance. For Charles IV, this agreement allows him to contain England on two fronts at once: in the southwest through the question of Aquitaine, and in the north through support given to the Scottish kingdom.

Isabella of France meets her brother Charles IV in Paris: Loyset Liédet, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

This diplomatic pressure intervenes at a moment when the English monarchy is passing through a profound crisis. The reign of Edward II is already weakened by military defeats, by the unpopularity of his favorites, and by divisions within the nobility. His wife, Isabella of France, sister of Charles IV, has been sent to the continent as part of negotiations between the two crowns. But instead of returning durably to England, she gradually distances herself from the king and draws closer to Roger Mortimer, a great English lord who has entered into rebellion against the regime and has taken refuge in France after his escape. Their alliance, both political and personal, becomes within months the center of opposition to Edward II’s government.

The situation tips in autumn 1326. Deprived of genuine direct French support, Isabella and Mortimer find backing in the Low Countries, particularly in Hainaut, where they obtain financial and military means in exchange for a matrimonial alliance project between the English heir apparent and Philippa of Hainaut. They land in England on September 24, 1326 with a relatively small force, but royal power disintegrates very quickly: many nobles, bishops, and officers abandon the king’s side and rally to the invaders. The operation, more political than military in origin, transforms into a general collapse of the regime.

Edmund FitzAlan and Hugh the Despenser the Younger are brought as prisoners before Queen Isabella of France: AnonymousUnknown author, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The first targets are the king’s two favorites, hated symbols of his government. Hugh the Despenser the Elder is captured at Bristol and executed on October 27, 1326. His son, Hugh the Despenser the Younger, the king’s principal adviser and favorite, is arrested in turn and then executed on November 24 under particularly brutal conditions. Meanwhile, the king himself is captured in autumn and is now at the mercy of his adversaries. The destruction of the Despenser faction deprives the sovereign of his last solid supports and opens the way to his deposition.

In January 1327, Edward II is officially deposed, and his son is proclaimed king under the name of Edward III. The new sovereign, still a minor, reigns first under the guardianship of his mother Isabella and Roger Mortimer, who effectively control English power. For France, this palace revolution has important consequences. It ends the reign of the prince with whom Charles IV had entered into conflict in Gascony, but it does not thereby resolve the fundamental question: the place of the king of England as vassal of the king of France for his continental possessions. On the contrary, the English dynastic crisis of 1326-1327 prepares a new political balance, soon dominated by the rise to power of Edward III, the future opponent of the Valois.

The episode finally shows how much the external policy of Charles IV’s reign remains closely tied to European dynastic affairs. Through his sister Isabella, the king of France becomes indirectly entangled in the collapse of Edward II’s regime. This family proximity does not lead to a lasting rapprochement between the two monarchies, but rather underscores the growing interlinking of ties of kinship, vassalage, and rivalry that structure Franco-English relations on the eve of the great succession crisis of 1328.

---

In the Kingdom of France, the same years witness the continuation of several internal developments. The Bourbonnais is elevated to a dukedom at the end of 1327, which illustrates the growing importance of certain great princely houses in the balance of the kingdom. Despite apparent institutional continuity, the final years of Charles IV thus remain traversed by major diplomatic tensions and by the involuntary preparation of a great succession crisis.

---

III. 1328: The Death of Charles IV and the End of the Direct Capetian Line

The death of Charles IV the Fair on February 1, 1328, opens a decisive succession crisis in the history of French monarchy. Like his brothers Louis X and Philip V, the king dies without a surviving son. His wife, Joan of Évreux, is however pregnant, which leads to the establishment of a regency entrusted to Philip of Valois, son of Charles of Valois and first cousin of the deceased king.

The situation in 1328 differs, however, from that of 1316. The precedents established during the accessions of Philip V and then Charles IV had already excluded women from succession to the throne. But this time, the imminent extinction of the male line directly descended from Philip IV the Fair brings forward several possible claimants. Philip of Valois appears as the closest male relative in the senior collateral branch of the Capetians; Philip of Évreux, another cousin of the king, can also make good his dynastic proximity; finally, Edward III of England, grandson of Philip IV through his mother Isabella of France, makes known his claims to the crown.

The fundamental question then becomes whether a woman, herself excluded from succession, can nonetheless transmit a right to the crown. For the great lords of the kingdom and for jurists close to the court, recognizing such a principle would amount to questioning the successions of 1316 and 1322, as well as opening the possibility of a foreign sovereign, namely the king of England, on the French throne. In this context, the most politically acceptable solution consists in choosing the closest male relative through male ancestors, namely Philip of Valois. This interpretation will later be linked to the Salic Law, even if its explicit invocation remains subsequent.

A few weeks after the king’s death, Joan of Évreux gives birth to a daughter, Blanche, on April 1, 1328. This birth definitively rules out the hypothesis of a posthumous male heir and allows confirmation of Philip of Valois as king of France under the name of Philip VI. With this succession ends the direct line of the Capetians, opened in 987 with Hugh Capet. The disappearance of Charles IV marks thus not only the end of a reign, but also that of the “Capetian miracle” of direct succession from father to son, and it opens a new period in the kingdom’s history, soon dominated by the dynastic rivalry between Valois and Plantagenets.

---

🧠 Key Points to Remember

• 1322: Charles IV the Fair is crowned at Reims (last direct Capetian)
• 1323–1324: The Saint-Sardos incident triggers war with England
• 1323: Founding of the Company of Gay Knowledge in Toulouse
• 1326: Treaty of Corbeil with Scotland; fall of Edward II of England
• 1328: Death of Charles IV without a male heir; Philip of Valois becomes Philip VI
• Major Issue: End of direct father-to-son succession, establishment of the Valois, claims of Edward III of England